How to Thrift a Cottagecore Wardrobe (Complete Guide)

Building a cottagecore wardrobe doesn’t require a trust fund or a trip to expensive boutiques. In fact, thrifting is the most cottagecore way to build your closet—it’s sustainable, budget-friendly, and yields unique vintage pieces that mass-market retailers can’t replicate.

This guide teaches you exactly what to look for, where to shop, and how to turn secondhand finds into a cohesive cottagecore wardrobe.

Why Thrifting is Perfect for Cottagecore

Thrifting aligns perfectly with cottagecore values:

Sustainability: Reusing clothing reduces waste and environmental impact
Authenticity: Vintage pieces have genuine character and history
Quality: Older garments were often made better than modern fast fashion
Uniqueness: You won’t see your outfit on everyone else
Affordability: Build a beautiful wardrobe on any budget
Slow fashion: The hunt itself becomes a mindful activity

What to Look For: Dresses

1970s Prairie Dresses

The holy grail of cottagecore thrifting. Look for:

High necklines with lace or ruffle trim
Puff sleeves (short or long)
Flowing, full skirts
Calico prints, small florals, gingham
Natural fabrics (cotton, cotton blends)
Brands: Gunne Sax (highly collectible), Jessica McClintock, handmade pieces

Price range: $15-$50 at thrift stores; $50-$200+ for Gunne Sax on resale platforms

Floral Midi & Maxi Dresses

From the 80s and 90s—often overlooked but perfect for cottagecore:

Muted floral prints on dark or cream backgrounds
Button-front or wrap styles
Rayon, cotton, or cotton-blend fabrics
Modest necklines and longer lengths

White Cotton Dresses

Eyelet, lace, embroidered—any white cotton dress with feminine details works:

Summer dresses from any decade
Communion or confirmation dresses (for shorter styles)
Nightgowns that could pass as dresses

Linen Dresses

Often found in the “grandma” section of thrift stores:

Simple shift or A-line shapes
Neutral colors: cream, sage, dusty rose, natural linen
Can be refashioned with minor alterations

What to Look For: Tops

Peasant & Poet Blouses

Look in multiple sections—women’s, vintage, even costume:

Gathered necklines (can be worn on or off shoulder)
Bell or puff sleeves
Embroidery, lace trim, or eyelet details
Cotton, linen, or cotton blends
Hungarian, Mexican, and Romanian embroidered blouses are perfect

Flannel Shirts

Men’s section often has the best options:

Muted plaids: forest green, rust, cream combinations
Soft, worn-in fabrics (avoid stiff new-looking ones)
Oversized for layering

Knit Sweaters & Cardigans

Cable-knit in cream, oatmeal, or sage
Wool or wool-blend (check for moths!)
Grandpa cardigans with interesting buttons
Fair Isle or folk patterns

Victorian-Style Blouses

High necklines with lace or pintucks
Leg-of-mutton sleeves
White or cream cotton
Often found in formal or vintage sections

What to Look For: Bottoms

High-Waisted Jeans

Vintage denim is superior to modern equivalents:

True high-rise (above the belly button)
Straight leg or slight bootcut
Medium to light wash
Brands: Levi’s (especially 501s), Wrangler, Lee

Fit tip: Vintage sizing runs smaller. Check measurements, not size labels.

Corduroy Pants & Skirts

Earthy tones: brown, rust, olive, cream
High-waisted styles
Wide or straight leg for pants
A-line or midi for skirts

Long Flowing Skirts

Broomstick skirts from the 90s
Tiered cotton or rayon skirts
Vintage wool skirts in winter weights
Maxi lengths in solid colors or subtle prints

What to Look For: Outerwear

Chore Coats & Work Jackets

Check men’s section for authentic workwear:

Canvas or duck cotton
Olive, tan, or navy
Brands: Carhartt, Dickies, vintage French chore coats

Wool Coats

Vintage wool coats in camel, cream, or muted colors
Check for moth damage carefully
Look for interesting collars, buttons, or belts

Denim Jackets

Vintage Levi’s or Wrangler
Medium wash, slightly oversized
Well-worn and soft

What to Look For: Accessories

Bags

Wicker and straw baskets (check hardware and condition)
Leather satchels and crossbody bags
Canvas totes
Vintage purses in neutral colors

Scarves

Silk scarves with floral prints
Wool scarves in solids or plaids
Bandanas in subtle prints

Jewelry

Vintage brooches
Pearl necklaces and earrings
Cameos and lockets
Gold-tone chains and delicate pieces
Pressed flower jewelry

Hats

Straw sun hats
Wool berets
Vintage scarves for headscarves

Where to Thrift

Best In-Person Options

Goodwill: Hit or miss, but good prices. Visit often.
Salvation Army: Similar to Goodwill, regional selection varies
Local charity thrift stores: Often better curation than chains
Estate sales: Excellent for vintage pieces and quality items
Church rummage sales: Hidden gems at rock-bottom prices
Vintage shops: Pre-curated but higher prices
Consignment stores: Quality pieces, mid-range prices

Online Thrifting

Depop: Good for vintage and trendy cottagecore pieces
Poshmark: Wide selection, can negotiate prices
ThredUp: Huge inventory, searchable by style
eBay: Best for specific vintage items (Gunne Sax, Levi’s)
Etsy: Curated vintage, higher prices but quality selection
Facebook Marketplace: Local pickup, often great prices

Thrifting Tips & Strategies

Before You Go

Know your measurements (bust, waist, hips, inseam)
Wear easy-on, easy-off clothing for trying on
Bring a phone charger (for price checking, inspiration)
Have a mental list of what you need
Set a budget to avoid impulse buying

In the Store

Check every section: Don’t skip men’s, kids’, or housewares (for textiles)
Look at fabric first: Touch everything—natural fibers feel different
Check construction: Seams, hems, buttons, zippers
Inspect for damage: Stains, holes, missing buttons, stretched elastic
Try everything on: Sizing is inconsistent, especially vintage
Think creatively: Can it be altered? Styled differently? Repurposed?

Evaluating Finds

Ask yourself:

Does it fit well or can it be easily altered?
Is the fabric quality and condition good?
Will I actually wear this, or just admire it?
Does it work with things I already own?
Is the price fair for the item’s condition?

Alterations & Refashioning

Don’t pass on pieces that need minor work:

Easy DIY Fixes

Hemming too-long skirts or dresses
Replacing buttons with vintage ones
Adding a belt to define waist
Taking in side seams
Shortening sleeves

Worth a Tailor

Taking in shoulders (complicated)
Replacing zippers
Significant resizing
Relining vintage pieces

Refashioning Ideas

Turn a too-short dress into a top
Add lace trim to plain items
Dye faded pieces (natural dyes for extra cottagecore points)
Combine elements from two damaged pieces

Building a Cohesive Wardrobe

Tips for making thrifted pieces work together:

Stick to a color palette: Cream, sage, dusty rose, brown—whatever your “colors” are
Mix eras thoughtfully: 70s prairie + 90s denim works; don’t get too costumey
Balance statement pieces: One vintage statement piece with simpler basics
Invest in quality basics: Sometimes new basics fill gaps between vintage finds
Curate ruthlessly: Don’t keep items just because they were a good deal

Thrifted Outfit Formulas

Everyday Cottagecore

Floral midi dress + cardigan + ankle boots

Casual Weekend

Vintage Levi’s + peasant blouse + basket bag

Layered Look

Turtleneck + pinafore dress + wool cardigan + boots

Summer Simple

White cotton dress + straw hat + sandals

Autumn Cozy

Flannel shirt + corduroy skirt + tall boots + wool scarf

FAQs

How do I find cottagecore items among all the stuff?

Train your eye to spot natural fabrics, muted colors, and vintage details. Skip the polyester, neon colors, and modern logos. With practice, you’ll scan racks quickly.

What if thrift stores in my area are picked over?

Try different neighborhoods, especially affluent areas or smaller towns. Estate sales and church sales often yield better finds. Online thrifting opens up national inventory.

How do I deal with thrift store smell?

Wash items immediately (or dry clean delicates). Sun and fresh air work wonders. Baking soda or white vinegar in the wash helps. The smell always fades.

Is it okay to buy fast fashion too?

A mixed approach is realistic. Thrift what you can, buy new basics if needed, and always prioritize quality over quantity. Don’t let perfect be the enemy of good.

Disclosure: Some links may be affiliate links. Read our disclosure.